Merisphere Publishing
Merisphere Research
Research article · Law
Law

Is Specific Legislation on SME Financing Needed in the OHADA Area? An Exploratory Study of the Canadian, Belgian and German Legal Frameworks

ENOGA Laurent François

Publication date :

Doctor/PhD in Private Law, University of Yaoundé II (Cameroon)Lecturer and researcher; part-time lecturer at the National Advanced School of Posts, Telecommunications and ICT and the Faculty of Economics and Management, University of Dschang.enogalaurent@yahoo.fr
2026-10-24

Abstract

Access to finance remains a structural obstacle to the development of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) within the OHADA area. The question, therefore, is whether adopting specific legislation could overcome the limitations of existing mechanisms. To address this issue, the present study uses a comparative legal approach to the Canadian, Belgian, and German models to identify mechanisms that can be adapted to African institutional realities. The analysis shows that effective financing depends on the articulation of diversified instruments, risk-sharing, regulation of credit granting, and secure debt recovery. Their transplantation nevertheless requires normative adaptation. Complementary legislation to OHADA law could therefore strengthen finance providers' confidence and provide lasting support for entrepreneurship.

Keywords: OHADA; SMEs; financing; comparative law; guarantees; credit security.

INTRODUCTION

In sub-Saharan Africa, access to finance for small and medium-sized enterprises remains a long-standing problem, as the constraints that impede it compromise their emergence, survival and competitiveness. As Julien Lefilleur notes, these enterprises face difficulties stemming in particular from the cost of risk, high transaction costs, and inadequate collateral for credit. Despite their contribution to economic activity, SMEs, which form the backbone of African economies, still face financing mechanisms that do not fully meet their needs. Yet, while SME financing is a major challenge, private-sector development is an essential driver of economic growth and job creation. This requires entrepreneurs to access suitable financial instruments and a legal environment that secures relationships among borrowers, lenders, and investors.

Financing difficulties do not arise solely from insufficient resources; they also result from information asymmetries, risk assessment, and the guarantees businesses must provide. As one researcher has observed, even in favourable contexts, examining bank financing for very small enterprises is far from straightforward. Reflection on SME financing must therefore assess whether existing legal arrangements are appropriate. Financing needs also vary by business life cycle: start-ups seek seed capital, operating businesses need working-capital resources, and firms pursuing growth seek investment and expansion finance. Uniform financing requirements that fail to account sufficiently for these differences risk excluding the most vulnerable firms. Accordingly, the OECD stresses the importance of diversifying financing instruments and sources to support SME investment and competitiveness. This raises a fundamental question: should the Member States of the Organisation for the Harmonisation of Business Law in Africa adopt legislation specifically devoted to SME financing to overcome the limitations of existing mechanisms and promote sustainable development? This study answers in the affirmative, provided that such legislative intervention offers genuine added value and is harmoniously coordinated with OHADA uniform law and national legislation. The Canadian, Belgian and German models provide useful comparative material for examining the diversity of support instruments and the conditions under which they might be adapted to African realities.

This study has a twofold interest. Theoretically and practically, it seeks to identify the legal conditions for more accessible and better-secured financing. Scientifically, it aims to contribute to the debate on the desirability of a specific legislative framework without assuming that creating a statute would, by itself, provide a sufficient solution. The analysis will therefore first examine the economic and legal foundations for establishing a specific legislative framework for SME financing in the OHADA area (I), then consider, in a second part, the legal architecture of such legislation, balancing the adaptation of financing instruments with creditor security (II).

I. THE ECONOMIC AND LEGAL FOUNDATIONS FOR A SPECIFIC LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK ON SME FINANCING IN THE OHADA AREA

The relevance of specific legislative intervention must be assessed in light of the economic constraints affecting SMEs and the legal requirements necessary to secure their financing.

A. Economic factors supporting the need for a legislative framework for SME financing

1. The structural vulnerability of SMEs in accessing finance

In sub-Saharan Africa, SMEs' vulnerability is particularly apparent in their difficulty in mobilising the resources required to create, operate, and develop. In UNIDO’s analysis, one indisputable reality is that Africa trails every other region in terms of investment profitability. More than ever, diversifying financial instruments and strengthening business-support services are decisive for the African private sector's financing model, especially because smaller firms face greater access barriers.

According to Julien Lefilleur, despite their contribution to economic activity, these firms still face limited access to finance, particularly because of constraints specific to African banking systems. Insufficient collateral, information asymmetry, and a high perception of the risks associated with their activities aggravate the situation. Financing difficulties not only jeopardise firms’ survival but also their capacity for innovation and growth. In this respect, the OECD notes persistent restrictive credit conditions and the relative insufficiency of long-term financing for SMEs, as well as the frequent failure to separate business finances from those of the owner and their family. The fragility of these firms therefore calls for institutional mechanisms that bring financial supply closer to the actual needs of the entrepreneurial fabric. For example, the West African Economic and Monetary Union’s SME/SMI financing support scheme combines business support, financial-institution intervention, and diversified financing instruments. Against this background, the Canadian experience deserves particular attention. The Canada Small Business Financing Act expressly seeks to increase the availability of financing for the establishment, expansion, modernisation and improvement of small businesses. Its adoption is part of a policy to reduce barriers to bank credit, as documented by Industry Canada.

However, a legislative scheme alone is not sufficient to guarantee effective access to credit. The African Development Bank also emphasises the importance of combining financial resources with technical assistance for SMEs. The German experience shows that even a developed financial system with specialised institutions does not necessarily eliminate difficulties in accessing capital, particularly for small firms and innovative young businesses. Some authors have identified difficulties within the German financial system in directing capital towards certain start-ups operating in new sectors.

Accordingly, SMEs' structural vulnerability justifies not so much abstract legislative intervention as an appropriate, operational normative framework aligned with institutional financing mechanisms.

2. Differentiating financing needs according to the SME life cycle: start-up, operation and development

The relevance of a legislative framework for SME financing in Africa depends first on its ability to take account of the diversity of their financing needs. The resources required to create a business do not meet the same economic requirements or repayment constraints as those intended to finance its operations or expansion. This differentiation therefore calls for a normative approach based on the firm’s life cycle and the nature of the needs to be met, while taking account of the firm’s financing choices. At the start-up stage, businesses face, in particular, a lack of a financial track record, insufficient collateral, and uncertainty about project profitability. These features intensify information asymmetry between entrepreneurs and capital providers, thereby increasing financing constraints. During the operating phase, by contrast, needs mainly concern cash flow, inventories, wages and current expenditure. Meeting them requires instruments flexible enough to avoid liquidity shortages without excessively increasing indebtedness.

In this respect, Canada’s small-business financing programme covers, among other things, working-capital financing and certain operating expenses. The development phase, moreover, requires resources suited to productive investment, innovation and commercial expansion. The OECD recommends diversification of financing sources to meet firms’ differentiated needs and support their investment capacity. European SME-support instruments likewise recognise the need to combine investment finance, equity and quasi-equity according to the firm’s stage of development.

A specific law in the OHADA area would therefore benefit from functionally differentiating financing instruments by reconciling access to resources, their suitability for economic needs, and the sustainability of SMEs’ financial commitments. Such differentiation would not indiscriminately seek to guarantee financing for every business, but rather facilitate access to resources for economically viable projects while preventing over-indebtedness and preserving the legal security of financing partners.

B. The legal foundations for normative intervention in support of SME financing

1. Sustainable mobilisation of private capital through legal incentive mechanisms

The sustainable mobilisation of investors is a determining issue for any legislative policy on SME financing. Insufficient resources alone do not explain difficulties in accessing credit, which also arise from perceived risk, the cost of assessing it, and uncertainty about recovery. Legislative intervention must therefore reconcile incentives to finance private initiative with protection for capital providers. The Canadian experience illustrates the value of a risk-sharing mechanism between the State and lending institutions. Introduced in 1961 as the Small Business Loans Act, Canadian legislation evolved into the Canada Small Business Financing Act 1998, which aims to increase credit availability for the establishment, expansion, modernisation, and improvement of small businesses. The scheme relies on private financial institutions to which the State provides, under certain conditions, a guarantee covering a share of eligible losses. It thus reduces lenders’ exposure without eliminating their duty to assess borrowers’ creditworthiness.

Sustainable mobilisation of private capital also requires diversification of financial instruments according to the SME’s needs. Berger and Udell show that financing needs evolve with business maturity and call for different methods of mobilising resources. Similarly, the OECD emphasises the importance of developing financing sources that complement bank credit. Applied to the OHADA area, this experience suggests a legislative framework that organises guarantees, co-financing, and investment incentives in accordance with applicable banking regulations. One option would be to integrate an SME credit-guarantee fund into the OHADA area as a central mechanism governed by a statutory risk-sharing regime. Legislation could establish, in each Member State or within a regional framework, a guarantee fund responsible for covering a defined proportion of eligible losses incurred by financial institutions granting credit to qualifying SMEs. Its operation would need to address, among other matters, eligibility, the guarantee ratio, lender due diligence, compensation procedures, and abuse prevention. Beyond the guarantee fund, the law should establish a legal regime for public guarantees and counter-guarantees governing relations between the fund, lending institutions, any mutual guarantee societies and other guarantee bodies already operating in the OHADA area. The framework should also include financial and tax incentives conditional on effective SME financing, together with an inclusive financing mechanism suited to innovative enterprises, start-ups and net-ups. Finally, the legislation could provide a risk-sharing regime accompanied by transparency and oversight obligations, since the scheme's credibility depends on its governance. It would therefore need to specify licensing conditions for participating bodies, beneficiary-selection rules, methods for calculating guarantees, audit mechanisms and reporting obligations.

The objective, therefore, is not to mechanically transplant the Canadian model but to establish a legally secure risk-sharing arrangement that can sustainably mobilise private capital to support SME growth, rather than merely proclaiming a right of access to credit.

2. Legally securing SME credit by adapting guarantee and risk-cover mechanisms

Loan guarantees are a decisive instrument for reducing credit risk and, correspondingly, widening SMEs’ access to finance. However, their effectiveness depends less on formal legal recognition than on accessibility, institutional credibility, and implementation arrangements. The Canadian, Belgian, and German experiences identify several mechanisms that can inspire reform adapted to the OHADA area. The Canada Small Business Financing Act establishes a mechanism to share eligible losses between the State and lending institutions to facilitate financing for businesses that struggle to obtain credit on ordinary terms.

In Belgium, regional guarantee schemes, particularly in the Flemish Region and the Brussels-Capital Region, support businesses that are insufficiently covered by the security ordinarily required. This organisation shows the importance of public intervention tailored to territories' economic and institutional characteristics, rather than a uniform mechanism disconnected from firms’ needs. In Germany, publicly supported Bürgschaftsbanken guarantee certain loans to SMEs where ordinary collateral is insufficient. Federal schemes can cover up to 80 per cent of the guaranteed credit, depending on the applicable conditions.

Within the OHADA area, the Uniform Act Organising Securities of 15 December 2010 already governs personal and proprietary security interests, including suretyships and autonomous guarantees. However, these mechanisms are not equivalent to an institutional guarantee fund intended to facilitate SME access to credit. As noted above, specific legislation should therefore establish public or mixed guarantee mechanisms subject to transparent eligibility, risk-sharing, and oversight criteria, without displacing uniform securities law.

II. THE LEGAL ARCHITECTURE OF AN SME FINANCING LAW IN THE OHADA AREA: ADAPTING FINANCING INSTRUMENTS WHILE SECURING CREDITORS

In our view, effective legislation requires aligning SMEs’ financing needs with the security of credit operations and the protection of financing partners.

A. Establishing a differentiated legal regime for access to financing adapted to SME needs

1. Diversifying financing instruments according to SME needs and maturity

The effectiveness of SME financing legislation depends on its ability to diversify financial instruments by business maturity and the nature of financing needs. In Canada, the Canada Small Business Financing Act facilitates access to credit for, among other things, productive investment and certain operating expenses. In Belgium, the Flemish Participatiemaatschappij Vlaanderen (PMV) scheme combines loans, co-financing, and guarantees, allowing financial support to adapt to business needs and reduce barriers caused by insufficient collateral. Germany similarly uses promotional loans from the Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau (KfW), including the ERP-Förderkredit Gründung und Nachfolge for business creation, succession and development. These experiences converge on the need to avoid a financing model based exclusively on bank credit that excludes firms whose needs, collateral or repayment capacity differ. The OECD recommends diversifying financing sources, including credit, equity, and asset-based instruments.

In the OHADA area, however, such diversification must be coordinated with uniform securities law, which governs the guarantees available in support of credit. Specific legislation could therefore establish a coordinated financing framework that combines credit, guarantees, and equity contributions according to SMEs’ actual needs. The question is how to organise such a framework legally without encroaching on OHADA law, since the essential difficulty lies in allocating normative competences. In any event, a special law on SME financing in the OHADA area should not create a competing regime for securities or debt recovery already harmonised under OHADA law, thereby simply juxtaposing credit, guarantee and investment mechanisms. The underlying idea should instead be to organise their functional complementarity by taking account of the SME’s stage of development, the nature of the financing need, repayment capacity and the level of risk associated with the project, without compromising the legal security of financing partners.

2. Establishing legal and financial mechanisms to support SME solvency and investment capacity

Improving SME access to financing cannot come from diversifying credit instruments alone. It also requires mechanisms designed to strengthen solvency and reduce the risk borne by lending institutions. Insufficient equity, weak collateral, and irregular cash flows all hinder access to appropriate financial resources. Legislative intervention must therefore balance easing access-to-credit constraints with preserving financial discipline. The Canadian model is particularly relevant in this respect. The Canada Small Business Financing Act, S.C. 1998, c. 36, establishes a risk-sharing scheme between the State and financial institutions to facilitate financing for small businesses. The mechanism does not replace prior credit-risk assessment; it improves risk coverage to encourage lenders to finance economically viable operations.

In a comparable approach, the Walloon Region in Belgium combines partial guarantees and subordinated loans through the “Garantie Online” and “Prêt Online” schemes. In Germany, the ERP-Förderkredit Gründung und Nachfolge programme combines promotional financing with a guarantee from a guarantee bank (Bürgschaftsbank). For the OHADA area, these experiences support legislation establishing guarantee funds, co-financing mechanisms, and risk-proportionate support, in coordination with the Uniform Act Organising Securities. In specie, the aim is not to substitute public authorities for the lender, but to make viable projects financeable without compromising credit security.

B. Establishing a regime for securing financing operations and protecting financing partners

1. Legal regulation of access to credit and the security of relations between SMEs and their financing partners

Securing SME financing operations requires a legal framework that balances more flexible access to credit with protection of financing partners' proprietary interests. Regulation must define the respective due-diligence obligations of the applicant, lender and, where applicable, guarantor, from preparation of the application through to performance of contractual obligations. Such an approach also involves incubation structures, whose support can help assess projects' organisational maturity and economic viability.

In Belgium, the Law of 21 December 2013, which contains various provisions on SME financing, provides a particularly relevant illustration of such regulation. Article 4 requires the lender, credit intermediary, and enterprise to act in good faith and fairly, and requires communicated information to be accurate, clear, and not misleading. Article 5 further provides for collecting information needed to assess project feasibility, the applicant’s financial position, and repayment capacity. Article 6 completes the scheme by requiring consideration of the type of credit suited to the firm’s situation and the purpose of the financing.

In Canada, the Canada Small Business Financing Act pursues a complementary objective by facilitating small-business access to finance through a risk-sharing mechanism between the State and participating lenders. Eligibility does not, however, confer any automatic right to obtain credit, since the financial institution remains responsible for assessing risk and deciding whether to grant the loan. The applicant must negotiate with a participating lender and prepare an application that meets the lender’s requirements. The applicant may seek a term loan to finance specified expenses or a line of credit, understood as a facility allowing funds to be drawn up to an authorised limit to cover current needs. Eligibility therefore does not guarantee approval, because the lender's assessment of the application and risk remains decisive. After examination, the lender approves or rejects the request. Where credit is granted, required security depends in particular on whether the loan is used for equipment, real property, leasehold improvements or intangible assets. The Canadian programme imposes a 2 per cent registration fee on the borrower and regulates both security interests and personal guarantees. The procedure clearly illustrates the need to combine banking due diligence, traceability and risk-sharing.

Similarly, in Germany, the KfW 077 programme combines preferential-rate credit with a full guarantee from a Bürgschaftsbank, subject to the applicable eligibility conditions. The scheme illustrates the complementarity between suitable financing and coverage of banking risk. Legislation on SME financing in the OHADA area should therefore regulate eligibility criteria, processing periods, transparency of pricing conditions, assessment of repayment capacity and proportionality of required guarantees. It should also organise guarantee mechanisms without encroaching on uniform securities law.

2. Organising procedures for enforcement of guarantees and recovery of financing claims

Where credit is repaid normally, no particular recovery difficulty arises. However, when the SME debtor defaults, legislation must provide financing partners with reliable, efficient, and legally secure mechanisms. The objective is to preserve continuity in the credit cycle without requiring the lender to bear the full consequences of a materialised entrepreneurial risk. The Canada Small Business Financing Act sets out a procedure governing the taking of security and the lender's claim for losses incurred. In the event of persistent default, the lender must undertake appropriate recovery steps, realise encumbered assets and document sums recovered or the economically justified impossibility of recovery. It may then submit a claim to the competent minister, together with documents establishing the loss amount. Administrative guidelines also provide for interim claims in certain circumstances and set time limits for their submission. Public guarantees should therefore not be regarded as automatic compensation for every unpaid claim: entitlement depends on compliance with statutory and regulatory requirements.

In Belgium, the Walloon “Garantie Online” scheme allows Wallonie Entreprendre to provide a partial guarantee for certain bank loans. In the event of default, activation of the cover remains subject to contractual conditions and the lender’s obligations. It is therefore distinct from prior recovery of the claim against the debtor. In Germany, the KfW 077 programme is based on a full Bürgschaftsbank guarantee for eligible financing. This cover strengthens lender security without eliminating the borrower’s personal responsibility or the scheme's specific conditions.

For the OHADA area, these models therefore suggest linking security enforcement, documented claims, and regulated compensation in a manner consistent with the Uniform Act Organising Securities. Special legislation could set time limits, specify supporting documents, define grounds for rejection, and set out arrangements for payment under guarantees, without derogating from uniform rules on recovery and collective proceedings. The objective would be to secure finance providers while, wherever possible, preserving the continuity of a viable enterprise.

CONCLUSION

From business creation through to consolidation, sustainable access to finance remains one of the principal challenges faced by small and medium-sized enterprises in the OHADA area. The difficulty does not arise solely from insufficient available resources; it also stems from a mismatch between financial instruments and firms’ different stages of maturity, limited available collateral, and uncertainty surrounding debt recovery. Mobilising private capital therefore requires a legal environment capable of reconciling financial inclusion for SMEs with security for the partners that finance them.

The comparative study of the Canadian, Belgian and German models highlights the value of normative intervention that combines risk-sharing, guarantee mechanisms, diversification of financing instruments, and regulation of claims procedures in the event of default. These experiences cannot, however, be transplanted mechanically into the OHADA area, given the economic, institutional and legal specificities of the Member States. They nevertheless demonstrate that the effectiveness of financing policies depends as much on the quality of support schemes as on the predictability of the rights and obligations of the actors concerned. From this perspective, adopting specific legislation on SME financing appears desirable, provided it does not duplicate mechanisms already established by the Uniform Acts. Its added value would lie in organising access to finance, differentiating support by business maturity, regulating lender due diligence, and establishing transparent guarantee and compensation mechanisms. Such intervention should also facilitate integrating accredited incubators into support for project promoters without making incubation an exclusive condition of access to credit.

Ultimately, the challenge is not so much to legislate more as to legislate usefully. A coherent articulation between OHADA community rules, national legislation and public financing schemes could strengthen investor confidence, support viable businesses and encourage the creation of sustainable employment. The desirability of a special law on SME financing in the OHADA area should therefore be measured by its capacity to transform the legal protection of financing into an effective instrument of entrepreneurial development.

Saving as PDF and printing are permitted for personal, teaching or academic use, provided that the title, author and Merisphere reference are retained.

Discussion of the article

This space welcomes comments, objections, bibliographical additions and scholarly developments arising from the article.

    No contributions yet.

    Contributions are published in accordance with Mérisphère’s rules for scholarly and editorial discussion.